CCS FAQ

Here are some answers to the most common doubts concerning CO₂ and CCS technologies in the context of decarbonization and energy transition.

faq-ccs-ravenna.jpg

Knowing, evaluating, understanding: transparency is a must

Are CCS initiatives dangerous? And do they really add value? What potential threats or benefits do they bring to the regions where they are located? The debate around carbon capture and storage intensifies with each new installation in the sector. In this section we present an overview of the key issues.

Is the complete abandonment of fossil fuels the only approach to eliminating CO₂ emissions?

Transitioning from fossil-based resources to renewable alternatives is critical to curbing carbon emissions, but it is not the complete solution. Several sectors will continue to rely on fossil fuels in 2050: in industries that require constant and high energy output (such as iron and steel, concrete and chemistry), in extensive and long-distance transport systems (including shipping, aviation and on-road freight transport). According to a report titled Global Renewables Outlook: Energy Transformation 2050, published by the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) in 2020, it is projected that on current trajectories, the global contribution of renewables will be 38% by 2030, rising to 55% by 2050. Under the most ambitious scenarios, these figures could rise to 57% and 86% respectively. Thus, even under the most optimistic of outlooks, the transition away from fossil fuels will take place gradually, underscoring the need for strategies that can immediately reduce their CO₂ output.

Learn more:
The role of CCS in the decarbonization strategy

 

Are CCS projects hazardous?

CCS uses safe technologies based on more than a hundred years of experience in natural gas storage. In addition, CO₂ is not flammable, explosive or poisonous. This is evidenced by its everyday use in fire-fighting, decaffeination, dry ice, dry cleaning and, of course, carbonated beverages.

Learn more:
What is CCS?

Is there a risk of CO₂ escaping from CCS storage sites?

Storage in depleted fields is both permanent and reliable. The likelihood of accidental leakage is zero because these sites are naturally sealed - as evidenced by their ability to spontaneously store and hold vast quantities of natural gas for millennia without leakage. 

Learn more:
What is CCS?

Could CCS operations cause earthquakes?

Eni and Snam's planned CCS projects have been carefully designed with seismic safety in mind. According to European guidelines, which are also followed by Italian regulations, it's forbidden to build storage sites in areas with high seismic risk (risk level 1). The storage sites selected for the Ravenna CCS project are outside these high-risk seismic areas. In addition, CCS uses a pressure that is not higher than the pressure of the original reservoir, when it contained natural gas. It is worth noting that in the long history of production in the areas off Ravenna and Liverpool Bay, there have been no recorded earthquakes associated with extraction activities.

Learn more:
What is CCS?

Could the high pressures used in CCS lead to incidents?

The pressure with which CO₂ is injected underground is rather low. Depleted or near-depleted reservoirs have internal pressures (fluid layer pressure) that are often well below their initial levels (hydrostatic pressure). Therefore, there's no need to achieve higher pressures to inject CO₂. In addition, the volume of carbon dioxide to be injected will always be less than the volume of methane previously extracted, ensuring that we never approach the reservoir's initial pressure levels. 

Learn more:
What is CCS?

What monitoring mechanisms will the Ravenna CCS use?

To further enhance safety, the Ravenna CCS will use advanced microseismic monitoring tools and techniques for detecting ground motion that have already been used in the Ravenna area to monitor subsidence associated with gas extraction. These monitoring methods, whether continuous or periodic, use cutting-edge technologies ensuring great precision and reliability. With decades of experience, Eni has acquired considerable expertise both in the use of these tools and in the interpretation of the data obtained.

Learn more:
What is CCS?

Is the hidden goal of CCS to produce more hydrocarbons?

It's important not to equate CCS with Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR), which is used in the US to increase oil recovery by injecting CO₂ into active reservoirs. In the context of the Ravenna CCS, storage will take place in depleted methane reservoirs that would be destined for definitive decommissioning. Once converted to carbon dioxide storage, these reservoirs will no longer be usable for production. 

Learn more:
What is CCS?

Is CCS speculative?

CCS is a technically mature process based on proven technologies. Its effectiveness is demonstrated by plants that have been in operation for many years. There are currently 33 operational CCS initiatives around the world, with a cumulative capacity of around 40 million tonnes per annum (Mtpa). In Europe, particularly in Norway, plants such as Snohvit and Sleipner have been operational since 2008 and 1996 respectively. 

Learn more:
The global context

 

Is actual CO₂ reduction significantly less than 90%?

Even after taking into account emissions from energy use during the carbon capture and compression process, the net reduction in emissions is between 70-80%. The exact percentage of reduction depends on the specific capture method and its industrial application. Today's methods can capture of over 90% of the CO₂ emitted from industrial chimneys, as widely demonstrated by plants currently in operation. As with most industrial processes, the capture of CO₂ and, to a lesser extent, its compression, requires energy and, depending on the source of this energy, may result in the release of CO₂. However, the effectiveness of current CCS methods, which is already impressive, will be further enhanced by technological advances and the predicted increase in renewable energy in the coming years, ensuring a supply of clean energy also for capture processes to be applied to “hard to abate” industries.

Learn more:
The role of CCS in the decarbonization strategy

Which countries use CCS?

More and more governments are directly backing domestic CCS projects to contribute to the decarbonisation of entire production districts.

With the introduction of the Inflation Reduction Act in 2022 in the United States, CCS projects are granted tax benefits as well as funds for research and investment in technology.
In the United Kingdom, the government has outlined a decarbonisation strategy with the aim of capturing and storing 20-30 million tonnes of CO₂ per year by 2030, accompanied by supporting policies worth around £20B, to attract private investment and lower market risk.

Norway is directly participating in the investments that will be needed to bring the Longship CCS project to fruition, contributing about 2/3 of the total value of the costs.
The European Union is also allocating funds, such as the Innovation Fund and the Connecting Europe Facility, with an increasing share regularly being allocated to CCS projects.
In addition, some EU Member states, including the Netherlands and Denmark, have provided significant support tools for the development of CCS technology and projects that will be able to help in achieving national decarbonisation targets. 

Learn more:

The global context